Claimline Services Member Contributions Sponsored by
Schaffer
Claims Specialists

Feature Article

CHALLENGING DOCTOR & HOSPITAL CHARGES
UNDER HEALTH BENEFIT PLANS & WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAWS

By: Lawrence P. Postol, Esquire
© 1997 Lawrence P. Postol
"Are you paying 100% of your medical charges for workers' compensation claims? The following outline describes the various legal avenues available for reducing medical charges...."
Read this Article or Return toArticle Index


CHALLENGING DOCTOR & HOSPITAL CHARGES
UNDER HEALTH BENEFIT PLANS & WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAWS

I Goal : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Control Health Benefit Costs
 
1. Cost Shifting
2. Controlling Costs
   
II Tools : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Health Benefit Plan (Insured or Self-Insured) and ERISA law.
 
1. Claim via ERISA Assignment
2. Defend Claim Against The Worker
   
III Limitations On Doctors' Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Reasonable and Customary
 
1. Reasonable: Excess Income
2. Customary: What The Doctor Charges Other Patients
B. Prevailing
 
1. CPT (Current Procedure Terminology) Code
2. 75th, 80th, 90th Percentile
C. Other
 
1. Misidentified or Unbundling of CPT Codes
2. Fraud
3. Unnecessary Care
4. Price Fixing
   
IV Limitations On Hospital Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Reasonable and Customary
 
1. Charge vs. Cost
 
a. Profit vs. Nonprofit
2. What The Hospital Collects From Other Payors
B. Inaccurate Charges
C. Other
 
1. Unnecessary Care
2. Price Fixing
D. Hill-Burton Act
E. Declaratory Judgment (Credit Bureau Attack)
   
V Doctors' Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A.. Price By CPT Code
B. Discounts For Medicare, Blue Shield, PPO's, HMO's
   
VI Hospital Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Target Income Pricing Based On Percentage Increases
B. No Relation To Cost
C. Different Departments Have Different Cost To Charge Ratios
D. Discounts For Medicare, Blue Cross, PPO's, HMO's (Contractual Adjustments)
E. Profits Even For Non-Profit Hospital
 
1. Build Empire
2. Nest Egg For Rainy Day
   
VII Challenging Doctor's Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Draft Health Benefit Plan To Allow Challenge
 
1. To Define
 
a. Prevailing: 80th/9Oth Percentile and HIAA Data
b. Customary: Lowest Non-Hardship Charge
c. Reasonable: Not To Exceed $200 Per Hour
d. Use of CPT Code
2. Administrator Has Discretion To Make Final Binding Decision
3. Insurer Administrated, but Self-Insured Avoids Mandated Benefits: Limit
 
a. Psychiatric
b. Chiropractic
c. Other Problem Areas
B. Create PPO or Use Managed Care Contract And Obtain Discounts
 
1. Trade Association/Employee Groups
C. Investigate Accuracy Of CPT Coding
 
1. Random Audits
D. Unnecessary Care
 
1. Utilization Review
E. Check For Fraud
 
1. Employee Review of Bill and Certification
   
VIII Challenging Hospital Charges : Return to Top : Exit Article
 
A. Obtain Medicare Cost Report Under Freedom Of Information Act
B. Obtain IRS Form 990 For Non-profit Hospitals
C. Obtain PPO, HMO, etc., Contracts In Negotiations or Litigation
D. Limit Payment To Cost Plus Reasonable Profit
 
1. Draft Health Benefit Plan To So Limit Reimbursement
2. Challenge Under Workers' Compensation Law
E. Create PPO or Use Managed Care Contract For Discount or Fixed Costs
F. Utilization Review
G. Accuracy Review
   

Return to
http://www.claimline.com


Claimline Services


Care to publish an article
or become a Claimline member?

E-Mail:

Membership@claimline.com

Comments or Suggestions?
E-Mail: Webmaster@claimline.com
Copyright ©1997 Claimline Services, Inc.

Last updated on Monday Nov 01, 1999 at 10:55 PM Relax!